No Discard of Stalin and Mao

(‘Democracy and Class Struggle’ has posted an article entitled ‘International Communist Movement and Mao Zedong Thought’ by  Harsh Thakor. This is a long but a very interesting and analytical article. This article has raised many questions regarding the debates on International Communist Movement, particularly the current Maoist Movement.

A true Marxist does not discard and minimize the contribution of Stalin and Mao.  Now we have Marxism–Leninism and Maoism as a Guiding Theory of Revolution.In this article, there are some issues to be discussed. But basically, we agree with Thakor’s analysis. We urge our Nepalese readers to study this article analytically and to participate in open discussions.

In this long article he has made UCPN (Maoist) also a subject of analysis and criticism. We are posting some interesting and key contents regarding the UCPN and other current issues. )

 

1.Trends
A major deviationist trend within the Marxist-Leninist Movement are the distortions of the polemics of Comrades Marx,.Lenin,Stalin and Mao Tse Tung .The chief proponent of this are the Nepalese U.P.C.N(M) and the Kasama group of U.S.A. Com.Mike Ely initiated the Kasama Project Group,a breakaway group from the R.C.P., U.S.A . The Kasama trend almost reduces Com Stalin to a non-Leninist and all Mao’s ideology as an anti-thesis of Stalinism..The Kasama project is one of the greatest ever Marxist-Leninist efforts to create a forum for debate, which has been lacking in the history of the Communist Movement ,but they deviate from strong theoretical foundation. Howevever its reading of Com.Mao’s cultural revolution and theories are virtually analyzed as something different or separate from Leninism.

The other trend that needs to be combated is that of Maoist third worldism propogated by the Leading Light Communist Organisation (LLCO)that advocates that the entire first world working class is reactionary and only the third world proletariat is revolutionary.It also upholds Lin Biao’s line as the revolutionary line as against that of Com.Mao Tse Tung. Infact it attributes the theory of Peoples War to Lin Biao.It slashes Bob Avakian from a left sectarian standpoint and even overlooks Avakian’s positive points.True it upholds Lenin and Stalin but claims that Com.Mao later veered towards revisionism with Zhou En Lai etc.

Both these trends are harshly critical of the R.C.P.(U.S.A) led by Bob Avakian but from deviationist perspectives. .Infact the R.C.P.took a progressive stand criticizing the Nepalese Maoists multi-party co-ordination and defended the vanguard role of the single proletarian party. Infact Kasama has taken several ecclectical positions on Lenin and the dictatorship of the Proletariat. They see Maoism as something anatagonistic to Stalin’s ideology and even different from Leninism. True they foster a democratic spirit of discussion and debate and welcome a huge range of views but basically do not derive at a proletarian class analysis.I consider the R.C.P.U.S.A more progressive than the Kasama or the L.lc.o.I feel Avakain makes some very valid points in democracy Can we do better than that?”True the R.C.P has fallen victim to losseness in theory and practice and hardly drawn out a mass revolutionary programme for the working class. Nor has it given adequate support to the third world movements. A revolutionary writer Joseph Ball,a staunch opponent of the rightist trends within Kasama is sympathetic to certain aspects of the L.L.C.O . But also partially to the R.C.P. Ball was critical of them Nepalese Comrades multi-party approach which Bob Avakain also opposed.

2. Multi-Party System
The most controversial trend within the Marxist-Leninist Movement is the finding fault with Comrades Lenin, Stalin and Mao and deploying of the multi-party System. The chief proponent of this are the Nepalese U.P.C.N(M) and the Kasama group of U.S.A. Com.Mike Ely initiated the Kasama Project Group,a breakaway group from the R.C.P., U.S.A . His writings slander the achievements of Com.Stalin to a considerable extent ,and even deride Com.Lenin and Com.Mao on many an occasion. The Kasama trend almost reduces Com Stalin to a non-Leninist and all Mao’s contributions achievements as an anti-thesis of Stalinism..True, Kasama project is one of the greatest ever Marxist-Leninist efforts to create a forum for debate, which has been lacking in the history of the Communist Movement .and made a historic contribution by launching outstanding debates on Maoist polemics .

However such forces are forgetting the important contribution of Lenin on the dictatorship of the Proletariat and the revisionist character of parliamentary democracy.Infact it was Trotsky who promoted the multi-party system and the institutions of bourgeois parliamentary democracy. By promoting multi-party system the proletarian revolutionary centre of power is denied and infact a Socialist State can be toppled. Let us remember the experiences of the Communist Movement in Nazi Germany or worldwide. It was the Leninist Party that promoted the building and consolidation of Socialist Societies in Soviet Union and China. Whether the Bolshevik Revolution,the civil War, the collectivization era, the Soviet World War Victory: all these achievements were the result of the foundation of the Leninist Party. Similarly in China although Mao called for continuous Revolution under the dictatorship of the Proletariat, he called for a revolt within a proletarian party Structure.

000

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply

See real websites hosted and built by iPage customers.

Warning: fopen(/home3/ayuryoga/public_html/sinusitiscare.com/wp-config.php) [function.fopen]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home3/ayuryoga/public_html/thenextfront.com/wp-content/themes/Thenextfront/footer.php on line 20

Warning: filesize() [function.filesize]: stat failed for /home3/ayuryoga/public_html/sinusitiscare.com/wp-config.php in /home3/ayuryoga/public_html/thenextfront.com/wp-content/themes/Thenextfront/footer.php on line 21

Warning: fread(): supplied argument is not a valid stream resource in /home3/ayuryoga/public_html/thenextfront.com/wp-content/themes/Thenextfront/footer.php on line 21

Warning: fclose(): supplied argument is not a valid stream resource in /home3/ayuryoga/public_html/thenextfront.com/wp-content/themes/Thenextfront/footer.php on line 22

Warning: mysql_connect() [function.mysql-connect]: Access denied for user 'ayuryoga'@'localhost' (using password: NO) in /home3/ayuryoga/public_html/thenextfront.com/wp-content/themes/Thenextfront/footer.php on line 43
ss